GNEE (Tianjin) Multinational Trade Co., Ltd
+8615824687445
Contact Us
  • Telephone: +86-372-5055135

  • WhatsApp / WeChat:+8615824687445

  • Mobile: +8615824687445

  • Mail:es@gescosteel.com

  • Address: No.4-1114, Beichen Building, Beicang City, Beichen District, Tianjin, China

Differences Between ASTM A123 and CSA G164-18

Jul 18, 2022

As an industry standard, ASTM A123 Standard Specification for Zinc (Hot-Dip Galvanized) Coatings on Iron and Steel Products establishes requirements for hot-dip galvanized coatings on various steel products. Most North American galvanizers use this specification as the standard for coating thickness, appearance, finish and adhesion. However, there are some competing specifications that attract attention when an end user asks a galvanizer to use them. For example, some customers in Canada may request that steel be galvanized according to CSA G164 Hot Dip Galvanizing of Irregularly Shaped Articles. Although this standard is similar to ASTM A123 in scope and purpose, there are many differences between the two. It is important to know these differences in case a manufacturer or specifier asks about CSA G164.


Previously, the CSA G164 standard had not been updated since 1992, and seemed to have lost relevance in the market and was little used. In 2018, G164 was updated to: include references to communication and power line hardware specifications, remove coating weight values ​​in favor of coating thickness values, revise material classifications and coating thickness minimum associated coating, and mention alternative galvanizing options (thermal diffusion galvanizing and mechanical galvanizing). Below is a review of the specification updates and a summary of the differences between ASTM A123 and CSA G164.

Scope and reference specifications

The scope of these two specifications remains almost identical in terms of the types of products that must be hot dip galvanized, but the new wording added to CSA G164 changes the main industry or market:


"This standard specifies the requirements for zinc coating (galvanizing) by the hot-dip process on iron and stele products intended or primarily for use in electrical and communication systems made of rolled, pressed, cast iron or forged as structural sections, plates, bars, tubes or sheets of 1 mm thickness and more."


To complement this change of focus in the electrical and communications industry, the new revision of the G164 also includes a new reference specification CSA C83, Communication and Power Line Hardware. Recently updated in 2017 (previous revision 1996), this reference standard provides utilities with a comprehensive list of electrical system line hardware components (including hot-dip galvanized), with critical performance criteria, dimensions, design and inspection.

Composition of the bath and purity of zinc

Although previously different, CSA G164 was updated to match the zinc bath composition requirement of ASTM A123. G164 requires that "...the galvanizing bath contain not less than 98.0% zinc by mass" while A123 states in section 5.5 that "the galvanizing bath...shall contain not less than an average value of 98.0% zinc by weight." Weight percent and mass percent differ only in wording and describe the same quantity. Both standards cite ASTM B6 as the standard for zinc to be used in the galvanizing bath, but ASTM A123 also accepts the B960 specification for recycled zinc.

Material categories and coating thicknesses

Each specification uses a table to describe minimum coating thickness standards for galvanized steel, but the minimum requirements and materials listed are quite different. Table 1 of ASTM A123 contains requirements for structural shapes, strips and bars, sheets, tubes and pipes, wires, and reinforcing bars. CSA G164 classifications are more general and include castings; rolled, drawn, pressed or forged steel; and screws, bolts, nuts, rivets, nails and similar fasteners. We can see that the first two general categories of G164 break down into the six specific categories found in A123. Additionally, A123 does not establish requirements for the minimum coating thickness of fasteners and threaded articles, but instead refers to ASTM A153 for these requirements. Both tables are shown below to compare the minimum coating thicknesses specified by each of them.


The most notable difference is that which refers to the minimum coating thickness required by standard A123 for tubes, as well as for straps and bars. Recent information has shown that coatings much thicker than these minimum requirements cannot be achieved with these materials. Despite this, the G164 standard groups this material with all the others and requires unattainable thicknesses for straps, bars, tubes and pipes.

CSA G164 Minimum Average Coating Thickness (μm) by Material Classification

Material Classification

Size/thickness

Minimum coating thickness (μm)

1

Iron and steel foundries

there

85

2

Rolled, drawn, pressed or forged steel articles (except classifications 3 and 4)

< 1.6 mm

1.6mm to < 3.2mm

3.2mm to < 4.8mm

>4.8mm

Acero estructural >6.35 mm and plates, not centrifuged

45

65

75

85

100

3

Screws, bolts, nuts, rivets, nails and similar fasteners

< 12,7 mm de diámetro


& Washers < 6.4 mm thick


42

4

Bolts, nuts and threaded fasteners

>12.7mm diameter


& Arandelas >6.4mm thick


65

ASTM A123: Minimum Average Coating Thickness (μm) by Material Category

Material categoryAll samples tested - Steel thickness range (measured), in. (mm)

<1/16 [<1.6]

>1/16 to<1/8 [>1.6 to<3.2]>1/8 to<3/16 [>3.2 to < .8]>3/16 to<1/4 [>4.8 to<6.4]>1/4 to<5/8 [>6.4 to<16.0]>5/8 [>16.0]
Structural forms45657575100100
Strip and Bar4565757575100
Plate4565757575100
Tubes and pipes454575757575
Wire355060658080
reinforcing bar----100100

Each standard lists the same tests that should be used to determine coating thickness on galvanized steel: magnetic or electronic thickness calibration methods, galvanizing weighing, strip weighing, or microscopy. The practice of each of these methods varies from specification to specification, but the most notable differences are those between magnetic and electronic thickness gauge measurements.


G164 requires that each coating thickness reading be at least 90% of the minimum thickness required in the table, and that the average of five measurements be equal to the minimum thickness required in the table. The A123 standard, in contrast, only requires that the average of the coating thickness measurements meet the minimum coating thickness required in Table 1 of the A123 standard, and that the average of a sample be one coating grade below of the requirement in Table 1 (as indicated in Table 2).


Sampling

Previously, the sampling procedure set out in G164 for checking coating thickness had very general and relaxed guidelines compared to the sampling procedure provided in paragraph 7 of A123. The G164 sampling procedure has been updated to reference the same sampling protocol as described in Annex B of CSA C83, Communication and Power Line Hardware.


Finish and appearance

G164 places few requirements on the appearance of the zinc coating. The specification does require that the coating be free of "...imperfections such as blisters; sandy or uncoated areas; acid, black spots, or slag particles adhering to the coating...". ASTM has a more realistic expectation that the coating be free of “…uncoated areas, blisters, flux deposits, and raw slag inclusions.” The key difference here is the disallowance of any slag particles adhering to the liner per G164. ASTM A123 also establishes a few more requirements on coating finish.


Adhesion and fragility

Both specifications require the use of a robust knife test to determine proper coating adhesion. However, G164 offers its own test procedures for strain embrittlement (bending or impact testing) while A123 references a comprehensive ASTM A143 guide detailing a bending test.


Touch up and repair

Touch-up and repair of hot-dip galvanized coating is performed in accordance with ASTM A780 for both standards. However, the two specifications contain a small difference in the maximum surface area that can be repaired after hot-dip galvanizing. Both specifications require that a bare spot must be less than one inch in its narrowest dimension and less than 0.5% of the coated area if it is to be repaired at the galvanizing plant. However, G164 3.3 refers to the "surface to be coated", while A123 6.2.2 refers to "the accessible surface to be coated on that article". This may seem like a small syntax difference, but this difference can turn out to be very important when considering overlapping areas (and the like). ASTM A123 also states, in addition to the 0.5% requirement, that "or 36 in2 per short ton [256 cm2 per metric ton] of part weight, whichever is less" is the smallest surface area allowed for renovation. before the part is rejectable.


The G164 standard does allow an exception to the maximum allowable repair size, stating that "any area larger than this may be renovated if the galvanizer and purchaser agree." ASTM A123 does not allow an exception to the maximum repair size allowed in the galvanizing plant. Another difference is related to repairs performed in the field, such as touch-ups after welding on the jobsite. ASTM A123 6.2.2 directly addresses the issue, stating that "once parts have left the galvanizing plant, there will be no limit on the size of the area subject to renewal." Although CSA G164 does not explicitly address field repairs, the same clause regarding mutually agreed upon repair size could be used.


Alternative galvanizing methods

CSA G164 includes a new informative Annex E on alternative galvanizing methods. The process and properties of thermal diffusion galvanizing (TDG) are described along with a reference to the associated standard ASTM A1059, Thermodiffusion Zinc Alloy Coatings (TDC) on Steel Fasteners, Hardware, and Other Products. Mechanical galvanizing is also referred to in accordance with ASTM B695, Mechanically Deposited Zinc Coatings on Iron and Steel, as an alternative galvanizing method.


Summary of differences

To fully understand the differences between CSA G164 and ASTM A123, you must read and fully understand each specification. However, the information presented here can adequately describe some of the main differences between the two.

Category

CSA G164

ASTM A123

Galvanizing bath

98% by mass

98% by weight

Zinc Purity

ASTM B6

ASTM B6 or B960

Max. Repairable AreaMax. Repairable area

<25 mm [1 pulgada] de ancho en la dimensión más pequeña y 0,5% del área total

Or, mutually agreed size

<25 mm [1 pulgada] de ancho en la dimensión más pequeña y 0,5% del área accesible o 36 pulg2 por tonelada corta

Repairs in the field

Not explicitly addressed

There is no limit on the size of the repair

Minimum coating thickness

Very general material categories (includes fasteners) with some unattainable thicknesses

Specialized material categories with thicknesses based on real-world information

Coating thickness measurement

Magnetic or electronic meter, galvanized weight, band weight, microscope

Magnetic or electronic meter, galvanized weight, band weight, microscope

Average coating thickness

Average of five thicknesses with all readings being at least 90% of the minimum required

Total average equal to the minimum coating thickness requirement of Table 1, with each specimen averaging more than one coating grade less.

Sampling procedure

CSA C83 Annex B


Finish/Look

No imperfections, including slag inclusions, are allowed

Raw slag inclusions are not permitted.

Accession

Robust knife test

Robust knife test

Fragility

Fragility tests due to deformation provided for in section 7.5 (bending and impact tests). There are no hydrogen embrittlement tests.

ASTM A143 Bending Test

Alternative galvanizing methods

Thermal diffusion galvanized (ASTM A1095)


Mechanical Galvanizing (ASTM B695)

N/A